Carrie Underwood’s Some Hearts, hastily made and released some five months after she won the 2005 American Idol crown, was surprisingly solid and tuneful. For her follow-up, producer Mark Bright steers her toward the big Martina McBride skies, with a plethora of strings and huge emotional crescendos. Underwood co-wrote four songs, mostly with the tried-and-true tunesmiths who made Some Hearts soar. On the torchy heartache ballad I Know You Won’t, she gives a beautifully nuanced and controlled performance, but if that song would suit any number of lush female pop stars from Celine Dion on down, Flat on the Floor rocks hard while preserving co-writer Ashley Monroe’s Appalachian angst. Still, there are missteps: the easy tears of the unlikely war ballad Just a Dream, a too-obvious attempt to repeat the sass of Before He Cheats ( The More Boys I Meet ), and the Shania-ish bad-girl-on-Cuervo stomp of Last Name. The big payoff, then, is how much 24-year old Underwood has improved as a vocalist. How often listeners line up for this Carnival Ride depends on their attitude about country music’s continual melding with pop, and how they feel about a princess upstart taking home the awards that used to go to her heroes.
More info:
http://www.amazon.com/Carnival-Ride-Carrie-Underwood/dp/B000VI70V8
Tracklist:
1 Flat on the Floor James, Monroe 3:20
2 All-American Girl Gorley, Lovelace, Underwood 3:33
3 So Small Laird, Lindsey, Underwood 3:46
4 Just a Dream Lindsey, McEwan, Sampson 4:47
5 Get out of This Town Lindsey, McEwan, Sampson 3:03
6 Crazy Dreams Dean, Underwood, Verges 3:38
7 I Know You Won t McEwan, Mobley, Thrasher 4:21
8 Last Name Dennis, Underwood 4:02
9 You Won t Find This Dennis, Shapiro 3:21
10 I Told You So Travis 4:19
11 The More Boys I Meet Kennedy, McEwan 3:34
12 Twisted James, Laird, Lindsey 3:57
13 Wheel of the World Lindsey, Lindsey, Mayo 4:42